Notes 7Z92 by Richard Pavlicek

Frequently Asked Questions

 1. What bidding methods are used?
 2. What defensive carding methods are used?
 3. Who are my partner and opponents?
 4. What do the various forms of scoring mean?
 5. How are the contests scored?
 6. What if I don’t like any of the answers listed?
 7. Shouldn’t each problem have a time limit?
 8. Can I use a computer program to find answers?
 9. Can I consult others about my answers?
 10. How can I find my past scores?
11. Why does your location list have unofficial countries?
12. What if I live in two different locations?
13. Do I have to use my real name?
14. Do I have to give you my e-mail address?
15. Will you give out my e-mail address?
16. How do you use my e-mail address?
17. How do I change my e-mail address?
18. How can I contact someone listed at your web site?
19. Why don’t you have a login and password?
20. Can I change my answers?
21. Can I change an answer and keep comments?
22. Can I amend my comments without changing answers?
23. How long can my comments be?
24. Are there any tips about writing comments?
25. If I miss the deadline, can I still enter?
26. Can I change or remove a comment after publication?
27. Why do you do this?

1. What bidding methods are used?

Bidding is “Standard American,” which includes strong notrumps (15-17), five-card majors and weak two-bids. Due to variations in American methods, specific agreements are based on my outline of Standard American Bridge and my more detailed Bidding Guide. Any problem scenario that does not conform to these bidding methods would be noted.

The default methods are deliberately simple and include only the most common conventions — Stayman, strong artificial 2 C bid, negative doubles, Michaels cue-bid, unusual notrump, regular Blackwood and Gerber.

Top of page

2. What defensive carding methods are used?

Whether you are declarer or a defender, it is important to know the carding methods used by the defense. Leads adhere to standard American practice, including king from ace-king, top of any other honor sequence, and fourth-best against all contracts. From three low cards, lead high at notrump and low at suit contracts.

Signals generally indicate attitude (high encourages, low discourages) when partner leads, or count (high-low with an even number, up-the-line with an odd number) when declarer leads. Special cases include the trump signal (high-low with an odd number) and suit preference. For clarifications and exceptions, see Carding Agreements in my outline of Standard American Bridge.

Exceptions occur, typically related to the contest theme, but these will be stated in the conditions for that event. (Particularly note “Beware the Ides of March,” in which your opponents use Roman leads and signals.) This is much like in real bridge, as from table to table you will encounter different methods.

Top of page

3. Who are my partner and opponents?

If your play or defense might depend on the skill of the players, you should assume all players are experts unless stated otherwise. (In some contests I state lower abilities or special characteristics to keep with the theme, and this takes priority.) Note that “expert” does not mean “superhuman,” as even experts make mistakes — just not many, and certainly not silly mistakes.

Top of page

4. What do the various forms of scoring mean?

For all problems (play or defense) the applicable form of bridge scoring is stated because this might affect your decision. Most of these should be familiar, but a brief explanation is given below. The list is in order of risk versus safety.

Matchpoints — commonly used in pair events. It pays to take risks to win the most tricks in the play. Overtricks are important.

Board-a-Match — similar to matchpoints, but you are playing to beat only one other result. Hence, each board is either a win (1), loss (0) or tie (1/2). Also known as “point-a-board.”

IMPs — commonly used in team events. Making or defeating a contract is the primary goal. Overtricks are less significant but should not be ignored.

Rubber Bridge — traditionally used for non-duplicate bridge. Safety is more important than IMPs, and overtricks are even less significant. Partscores carry over from deal to deal (within the same rubber) and honors count.

Chicago — similar to rubber bridge but more popular today. Each round consists of four deals with predetermined vulnerability rotation. Partscores carry over (within the round) and honors count.

Total Points — almost nonexistent today. Raw duplicate scores are added together. Safety is even more important than rubber bridge, and overtricks are insignificant. Honors count, but each deal stands alone (no partscore carryover).

Plus-or-Fishfood — invented by me (in jest) for “The Game Is Afoot” play contest as the ultimate in safety concern. The only object is to get a plus score, so overtricks are totally meaningless. Honors do not count.

Top of page

5. How are the contests scored?

Card play is generally objective; that is, it is usually possible to determine the best play or defense, even if this takes extensive analysis aided by computer. Answers are ranked by my judgment after lengthy study, which is aided by reading your comments, especially those from regular participants with proven ability.

Voting is used to break ties among answers that prove to be equal (or virtually so), and may also affect the actual awards given for also-rans. For example, if a poor play receives a lot of votes, I might score it as 3 or 4 instead of 1 or 2.

Scoring should not be considered final or “official” until at least two weeks have elapsed. While I take great effort to be fair in my grading, I am only human, and it is possible that I overlooked something. I invite feedback and often receive arguments that a play or defense deserves a higher award (nobody ever seems to complain about an award being too high). Sometimes I agree with these arguments, and the scoring may be adjusted.

Top of page

6. What if I don’t like any of the answers listed?

Each problem offers multiple-choice options for convenience, so it could happen that your desired play or defense isn’t listed. Chances are this means you were saved from a bad score, as I try to list all plausible options. Nonetheless, my listing is limited to six choices, so it is possible that a reasonable alternative exists.

In this case, simply vote for your second choice. Then use the comment box, if desired, to explain your true feelings and how you would prefer to play. Your score will always be based on the option chosen (almost surely to your benefit) regardless of comment, but don’t be afraid to tell me off if you feel strongly about something.

Top of page

7. Shouldn’t each problem have a time limit?

Ideally, yes, but for practical purposes this would be impossible to control or enforce. Therefore, participants can take as little or as much time as they wish. Bridge is a recreation, not a life threatening venture (some people would argue that), so the objective is to enjoy whatever time you spend on it. Scoring and rankings are mostly for fun, so don’t take them too seriously — unless you win, of course, then they’re meaningful.

I think most people understand that some participants answer quickly (as if they were at the table), while others devote a great deal of time to it. Either way is fine! (This accounts for the occasional mediocre score of some known excellent players.) The only thing that wouldn’t be fine is not to enjoy it — because then it may be time to take up canasta.

Top of page

8. Can I use a computer program to find answers?

Good question. Like the previous question, there is no way to regulate or control how answers are found, so I will have to say you can do whatever you enjoy. Keep in mind, however, that few problems are solvable by double-dummy analysis, because the matter of which hands might be held and the likelihood of each is subjective, based on various inferences (often subtle) from the bidding and play. Even with all my personal software, designed specifically for this task, it is often difficult to determine the best play. Also note that people seldom agree on subjective issues, and my eventual decision (made after reading comments) has to prevail.

For practical purposes, and certainly to improve your own play, you should try to emulate conditions at the table. Take extra time if you need it — no “slow play” warnings here — but your opponents might be upset (no kidding) if you punched a bunch of keys on your laptop and announced, “Claiming on a triple crisscross squeeze!” Seriously, even if you don’t select the optimal play in theory, pride yourself in choosing a reasonable play, as that’s how to keep up your scoring average. Sometimes, even my expected answer turns out to be worth only 7, 8 or 9 (LOL, maybe less if I didn’t set the awards) after extensive analysis.

Top of page

9. Can I consult others about my answers?

Sure. Again, the main point is to enjoy whatever time you spend on the contests. Bridge is a social game, so there is no reason not to maintain that environment. Discussing problems is quite normal, and there is nothing wrong with basing an answer on a friend’s advice, or changing an answer that you have been convinced is wrong — provided some of the input is your own.

Obviously, it would be wrong to copy another person’s answers and submit them as your own, as any respectable person already knows. Combined or group efforts are also discouraged, but there’s nothing wrong with a husband and wife confiding to submit a single entry if desired. It is preferred, of course, that spouses submit separate entries — and this also makes for a fun household contest, e.g., to decide who does the dishes next month.

Top of page

10. How can I find my past scores?

You can obtain a summary of all your past scores by clicking on
Get Your Scores (also available on the main page). Simply enter your name and e-mail address, and your score summary will be sent to you automatically and instantly. Just check your e-mail, and it should be there. The summary includes every event you participated in since January 2007.

Note that this retrieval method also maintains your privacy. If another person entered your exact name and e-mail address, he would not get your scores. Your summary can be sent only to your address.

Top of page

11. Why does your location list include non-countries?

The purpose of my location list is to identify where you live, not your citizenship or political allegiance. For example, if you’re a French citizen living in Bermuda, the latter is the proper location to choose. Some of the listed locations are unofficial countries*, though most are prominent enough to have unique ISO codes.

*Officially, there are 193 countries, but there are many other distinct geographic areas. My listing includes: American Samoa, Bermuda, Cocos Islands, French Polynesia, Greenland, Hong Kong, Puerto Rico, Reunion, Taiwan, Virgin Islands UK, Virgin Islands US, and Basque Country. The last is controversial and was added by request in 2001 (I hope no one draws any political inference, as I take no sides in the controversy).

Three countries are subdivided: United Kingdom is divided into regions (England, Scotland, etc.); United States into states; and Canada into provinces. The reason for this is to balance the number of participants per location. For instance, California alone has more participants than most countries; so considering the United States as a whole would be greatly out of proportion. Codes for subdivided countries are the ISO country code plus two lowercase letters; e.g., USfl = Florida, and CAon = Ontario.

My entry form now lists all locations (countries, unofficial countries, UK regions, US states and CA provinces) from which I have past participants, plus a few others where I believe bridge is played. If your location is not listed, please select “Other” and use the “Remarks” box to inform me, then I will add it to the list in the future. You are welcome to participate wherever you live.

Top of page

12. What if I live in two different locations?

If you live part of the time in one location, and part in another, select the location where you live most of the time (or the one you wish to be recognized by) then do not change back and forth based on your physical whereabouts. That is, use the same location each time, since my method of matching past participants is by name and location.

This situation is quite common in my own state (Florida), which has many residents who are snowbirds — winters in Florida, and summers someplace up north. Please decide which state you wish to be listed as, and stick to it whenever you enter.

Location changes should be made only for permanent moves, or moves with an expected duration of at least two years (such as attending college) in which case I will update my database accordingly. Also, if you change your location and nothing else, my web form offers a checkbox to indicate whether it is an actual move (previous location was correct) or a correction (previous location was wrong), so I know whether the change should be made from now on or retroactively.

Top of page

13. Do I have to use my real name?

Yes, my policy is only to accept entries with real names. If you enter as “The Dude” or “Fast Eddie,” you are wasting your time as it won’t be included. Each month I get from 10-20 such entries, which go straight to the junk box. I used to write these people as a courtesy trying to salvage the entry, but I usually got no reply; so now I don’t waste my time.

Note: If your name happens to sound phony, such as “Clark Kent” or “Bart Simpson,” please use the “Remarks” box to provide evidence that it’s real. If I’m not convinced, junk box. :)

Another problem I have with names is that people sometimes use their true first name, and the next time use a nickname (with the “Update info” box checked). I used to make these changes immediately, but then I noticed that some would switch back and forth (grr… wasting my time). Therefore, my current policy is not to change your first name to a nickname or shortened form unless you specifically confirm this desire with a note in the “Remarks” box.

Top of page

14. Do I have to give you my e-mail address?

Yes, as it is fundamental to the process. Every time you enter, a copy of your answers (and comments) is automatically sent to you as a confirmation. This not only provides an exact record of your entry but is a great convenience if you later decide to change any of your answers.

Obviously, there is no practical way to determine if the address you enter actually belongs to you; but it must be a valid* e-mail address. If I discover that someone has abused this process by deliberately submitting a false address, that person will be denied entry in the current and future contests.

*To minimize typos, addresses are scanned for proper syntax — one @ sign, at least one subdomain and a valid top-level domain (with dot separator), valid alphanumeric characters, etc. Tests are not foolproof, however, so it is possible that a strange but legitimate address is rejected. If this ever happens to you, please write me (richard@rpbridge.net) and I will adjust my screening test accordingly.

Top of page

15. Will you give out my e-mail address?

No. Your e-mail address is private and goes nowhere from me. Would I sell it? Hardly. I’m the kind of person who will stand by principles, so even Bill Gates couldn’t afford it. How about Bill Gates and Warren Buffet combined? LOL, I’m thinking.

Top of page

16. How do you use my e-mail address?

Once a month (about the 4th or 5th) I send an e-mail message to announce my current contest to all past participants. This message also contains a summary of the past month’s results, as well as some useful links, such as where to get your scores.

Nothing about this message is commercial, so it’s hard to imagine why any bridge player would find it unwelcome; but anyone who wishes to be removed, need only advise me. See my Removal page (also available on the main page).

Top of page

17. How do I change my e-mail address?

Each time you participate, your e-mail address is updated to the latest submission, so there is no need to do anything. Simply enter using your new address; and when prompted that it doesn’t match my records, select “Past participant, please update my info.”

See my Address Change page (also available on the main page) for more information.

Top of page

18. How can I contact someone listed at your web site?

Write me (richard@rpbridge.net) and give me permission to send your address to the person you wish to contact. I will e-mail that person with the subject, “Contact request,” and include your name and e-mail; then he or she can contact you if so desired. Please don’t bother to ask for someone’s e-mail address, as I will not give them out.

Top of page

19. Why don’t you have a login and password?

Because I think most people, like me, are fed up with this method. I like to believe these events are personal, and indeed I’ve made many new friends along the way. Further, this would complicate the entry process, and turn off people who might have participated — I know that whenever I come to a web site with a login-password box, it’s usually good-bye, as I won’t be bothered.

Going by names does add a complication: Matching participants from previous events. My policy is to match people by name and location (not e-mail address because this often changes). In the rare event of same-named participants from the same location, I ask for a middle initial — and if that’s the same, well, I won’t worry about it until it happens.

Top of page

20. Can I change my answers?

Yes! Most people are pleased with this feature, as it is much more comfortable to enter when you know it is noncommittal. At any time until the contest closes (multiple times if desired) you may change your answers. Just resubmit your entry, which automatically replaces the previous one. Only your latest entry counts, and it’s the only one I read and process at scoring time.

Keep in mind, however, that resubmitting answers will reset your date-time stamp, which is used as a tiebreaker. Thus, you will lose any tenure you may have accumulated by your previous entry. Sometimes, as in poker, it pays to “know when to hold ‘em.”

Top of page

21. Can I change an answer and keep comments?

Not by any automatic process, but this is easy to do. When you resubmit your entry, copy any comment you wish to keep (from your previous entry confirmation) and paste it into the web form. The “copy and paste” procedure works just as in any Windows program. Just remember: Your final entry always stands alone.

Top of page

22. Can I amend my comments without changing answers?

Again, only by the process described above. At present there is no provision to check if your resubmitted answers are the same, so your date-time stamp will be reset as usual. This is not a common occurrence, so I’ll keep the status quo.

Don’t worry about typos, spelling and grammar, as these will be corrected if your comment is used. Also, if you happen to realize that a comment is misworded or goofy, I will usually be able to fix it to what you intended — and if I can’t interpret what you mean, I won’t use it, so you won’t be embarrassed by the publication of an incongruous comment.

Top of page

23. How long can my comments be?

There is no precise maximum length*, but try to limit most comments to 60 words or less. Occasionally, however, feel free to write as much as you wish; but keep in mind that I do not publish long, rambling comments. Therefore, if you want a long comment to be used, it must be well written — otherwise, you’re wasting your time.

*Actually, my web form now enforces a limit of 50 lines (at 50 characters per line) for each comment. This is mainly to prevent abuse, such as someone pasting a huge file into the form. I doubt that anyone would ever want to write this much.

Sometimes I will use only what I feel is the best part(s) of a comment, indicating with an ellipsis (…) where text was cut. Usually, this is because the cut portion was already well stated; or it might be that you were too wordy; or drifting into a tirade.

Top of page

24. Are there any tips about writing comments?

Yes. I have a conversion utility to convert comments to my writing format. You can help by typing bridge hands in suit order, using a hyphen (-) only for a void, and without space between cards. For example, if you type AQTxx K9xx - jtxx, it will automatically be typeset as S A-Q-10-x-x H K-9-x-x D — C J-10-x-x. Please do not try to emulate the finished typeset appearance, as this only gives us both extra work. Below are some other tips:

Top of page

25. If I miss the deadline, can I still enter?

No. Almost every month someone e-mails me after the event has closed with some sob story, “Oh, please, the dog rebooted my computer!” Sorry, but rules are rules. Each contest ends at midnight (GMT) on the final day of the month — at the same time the next month’s contest opens. You have all month to enter, so don’t put it off until the last minute. Also, remember that your entry is noncommittal; you can change your answers later if desired.

People often ask why I go by GMT (Greenwich Mean Time) instead of U.S. Eastern Standard Time where I live. The main reason is that these events have global participation (90+ countries), and everyone should be familiar with their time difference from GMT. Also, midnight GMT is convenient for me, as the changeover occurs at 7:00 pm local time (8:00 pm during daylight savings). Note that GMT is constant (no daylight adjustment), so British Summer Time (BST) will be one hour later.

My current policy is to open each new event on-the-dot, synchronized by the U.S. Naval Observatory atomic clock. The closing event, however, is given a 5-minute grace period to allow for someone entering at the witching hour with a clock slightly slow. But whatever the case, once the contest is cut off, that’s it.

Top of page

26. Can I change or remove a comment after publication?

This is rare, but I don’t want anyone unhappy. If you do not like the way one of your comments appears, please let me know the desired change. I will then either correct it as you wish, or offer a possible compromise if the change means that I would not have chosen to use the comment. In the unlikely event we can’t agree, or if you desire, I’ll remove the comment.

Top of page

27. Why do you do this?

Uh-oh. I was hoping you wouldn’t ask that. Oh well; I suppose you’ll find out anyway. Every entry submission triggers a $29.00 transfer from your credit card to my Swiss bank account. The last time I checked I was packin’ away millions.

Seriously, I do it as a hobby, and as my way of contributing to the bridge community. Throughout my life, I’ve had little interest in promotion, marketing or finance — indeed, until a few years ago, I didn’t even know where the bank was. The regular activity also seems to help me emotionally in these trying times with my wife seriously ill.

Top of page

Copyright © 2007 Richard Pavlicek.