Main Column 7D99 by Richard Pavlicek
|6|| K 8 7|
K Q 9
K 9 6 5 4
| J 10 5 3|
10 8 5 4 3 2
| 6 4 2|
A J 6
Q J 10 7 3
|Lead: 4|| A Q 9|
A K Q J 9 8 4 2
The trouble began at Souths third turn. Over three notrump he could not ask for aces, since four clubs would be a club raise (Norths suit), and four notrump would be a quantitative invitation to six notrump. Therefore, South decided to gamble with a jump to slam a reasonable stab given the circumstances.
An expert would have avoided the pitfall by bidding just two diamonds at his second turn. (This is forcing since a two-level responder promises another bid.) Then over two notrump, a jump to four clubs would be the Gerber convention. When two aces are found missing, South would sign off in four notrump, the optimum contract.
West led the heart four, dummy played the queen, and East won the ace. East pondered his next play, and having the club suit bottled up he decided not to help declarer and exited with a trump. South certainly appreciated getting no help and quickly claimed his contract, stating he would discard his losing club on the heart king.
East and West glared at each other with daggers. No, wait! It may have been bananas, but whos counting. Why didnt you return a club? asked West. Why didnt you just lead your ace? countered East. Clubs was dummys suit; and even if I did lead it, how would I know to shift to a heart? argued West. So who gets the blame?
East was the fall guy. He should return the club queen, not only because West might have the ace but because West might be void. Further, if West held the spade ace instead of the club ace, a club return would not surrender the contract unless South held nine diamonds. Easts actual return of a trump had no merit in any layout.
© 10-7-1990 Richard Pavlicek